Millburn Township, home to the ultra-prestigious Short Hills neighborhood, represents the pinnacle of New Jersey luxury real estate. With a median home price of $1,318,800 and the #1-ranked school district in the entire state, Millburn Short Hills has become synonymous with excellence, exclusivity, and generational wealth building.
As a mortgage advisor specializing in Bergen and Essex County luxury markets, I've helped dozens of families secure financing for homes in this elite community. This comprehensive guide reveals everything you need to know about buying real estate in Millburn Short Hills in 2025—from market dynamics to financing strategies for high-net-worth buyers.
Why Millburn Short Hills Commands Premium Prices
The #1 School District Advantage
Millburn Public Schools consistently ranks #1 in New Jersey across all metrics: - Average SAT Score: 1410 (vs. 1060 state average) - College Placement: 98% attend 4-year universities - National Merit Scholars: Produces more per capita than nearly any district in America - AP Participation: 85% of students take AP courses - Graduation Rate: 99.2%
This educational excellence drives massive premium pricing. Families pay $400K-$600K more than comparable homes in neighboring towns purely for Millburn school access.
Generational Wealth & Legacy Buyers
Millburn Short Hills attracts: - C-Suite Executives: CEOs, CFOs from NYC financial firms - Medical Professionals: Surgeons, specialists from major hospitals - Entrepreneurs: Business owners who've exited companies - Legacy Families: Multi-generational residents (30%+ of buyers) - International Buyers: Families relocating from Asia, Europe for education
Median household income: $250,000+ (top 2% nationally)
Millburn Short Hills Market Breakdown 2025
Price Ranges by Neighborhood
1. Short Hills Village Core ($2M-$5M+) - Walking distance to train station (23 min to NYC Penn Station) - Historic estates, newer luxury construction - Lot sizes: 0.5-2 acres - Property tax: $45K-$80K annually
2. Millburn Center ($1.2M-$2.5M) - Downtown proximity, walkable lifestyle - Mix of colonials, contemporaries, Tudors - Lot sizes: 0.25-0.5 acres - Property tax: $30K-$50K annually
3. Glenwood/Wyoming ($1.5M-$3M) - Large estates, privacy-focused - Newer construction, renovated classics - Lot sizes: 1-3 acres - Property tax: $40K-$70K annually
4. Hartshorn/Old Short Hills ($2M-$6M+) - Ultra-exclusive, gated properties - Custom estates, architectural significance - Lot sizes: 2-5+ acres - Property tax: $50K-$100K+ annually
What $1.3 Million Buys You
At the median price point ($1,318,800), expect: - Square footage: 3,500-4,500 sq ft - Bedrooms: 4-5 bedrooms - Bathrooms: 3-4 full baths - Lot size: 0.4-0.6 acres - Age: 1950s-1980s (many renovated) - Style: Colonial, center hall colonial, expanded ranch - Garage: 2-car attached - Features: Updated kitchen, finished basement, hardwood floors
New Construction & Tear-Downs
Trending phenomenon: Buyers purchasing $1.2M-$1.5M older homes, demolishing, and building $3M-$5M custom estates.
- Tear-down candidate: $1.3M (0.5 acre lot)
- Construction cost: $1.5M-$2M (5,000-6,000 sq ft custom home)
- Total investment: $2.8M-$3.3M
- Completed value: $3.5M-$4.5M
- Timeline: 18-24 months
Financing Luxury Homes in Millburn Short Hills
Jumbo Loan Requirements (Loans >$766,550)
For most Millburn purchases, you'll need jumbo financing:
Minimum Requirements: - Credit score: 700+ (720+ for best rates) - Down payment: 20% minimum ($263,760 on median $1.3M home) - Debt-to-income: <43% (preferably <38%) - Reserves: 12+ months PITI (Principal, Interest, Taxes, Insurance) - Income verification: 2 years tax returns, W-2s, bank statements - Assets: Liquid reserves beyond down payment
Income Needed for $1.3M Home
Assuming 20% down ($260K), here's the math: - Loan amount: $1,040,000 - Interest rate: 7.25% (2025 jumbo rates) - P&I payment: $7,095/month - Property tax: $3,500/month ($42K annually) - Insurance: $400/month - Total PITI: $10,995/month - Required income (at 38% DTI): $347,000/year minimum
Portfolio Loans for High-Net-Worth Buyers
For buyers with significant assets but complex income (business owners, retirees): - Asset-based qualification: Use investment portfolios instead of income - Typical requirement: $2M-$3M in liquid assets for $1M+ loan - Down payment: Often 30-40% for best terms - Rates: Slightly higher (0.25-0.75% above jumbo)
All-Cash Buyers (40% of Millburn Market)
Millburn has unusually high all-cash purchase rate: - Faster closings: 2-3 weeks vs. 45 days - Stronger offers: Sellers prefer certainty - No appraisal contingency: Critical in competitive market - Bridge loans available: If liquidating other assets
Property Tax Reality: What You're Actually Paying
Millburn's High Tax Rate
Millburn's effective tax rate: 2.98%-3.2% of assessed value
On a $1.3M home: - Annual property tax: $38,740-$41,600 - Monthly escrow: $3,228-$3,467
What You Get for Your Taxes: - #1 school district in New Jersey - Excellent municipal services (police, fire, DPW) - Well-maintained parks, recreation facilities - Library system, community programs - Top-tier infrastructure
Tax Deduction Limits (Post-2017 Tax Reform)
SALT (State and Local Tax) deduction capped at $10,000: - Pre-2018: Could deduct full $40K property tax - Post-2018: Only $10K deductible - Effective cost: Higher for high-income buyers in top brackets
This impacts Millburn buyers more than most markets, but demand remains strong due to school quality.
Lifestyle: What Living in Millburn Short Hills Offers
Commute to Manhattan
- NJ Transit: 23-28 minutes to Penn Station (Short Hills station)
- Peak trains: Every 15-20 minutes during rush hour
- Monthly pass: $330-$400
- Parking: $150-$200/month at station
Many executives use commute time productively on the comfortable Midtown Direct line.
Downtown Short Hills & Millburn
Short Hills Village: - Upscale boutiques, cafes - Short Hills Mall (Neiman Marcus, Nordstrom, luxury brands) - Fine dining (Chez Catherine, Suburban Diner) - Walkable, charming downtown
Millburn Center: - Local restaurants, shops - Taylor Park (concerts, farmers market) - Community theater, arts venues - Family-friendly atmosphere
Country Clubs & Recreation
- Baltusrol Golf Club: Host of 7 U.S. Opens, ultra-prestigious
- Canoe Brook Country Club: Jack Nicklaus-designed course
- Short Hills Club: Tennis, swimming, social hub
- Cora Hartshorn Arboretum: Nature trails, education programs
- South Mountain Reservation: Hiking, biking, ice skating
Safety & Low Crime
Millburn consistently ranks among NJ's safest towns: - Violent crime: Nearly zero - Property crime: Extremely low - Police presence: Well-funded, responsive department - Neighborhood watch: Active community engagement
Who Should Buy in Millburn Short Hills?
Ideal Buyer Profile:
✅ Families prioritizing education: Willingness to pay premium for #1 schools ✅ High-income earners: $350K+ household income ✅ Long-term owners: 10+ year time horizon to recoup high entry costs ✅ NYC commuters: Value 23-minute train access ✅ Affluent lifestyle: Appreciate country clubs, luxury shopping, fine dining ✅ Low crime priority: Safety-conscious families ✅ Generational wealth builders: Viewing home as legacy asset
Who Should Consider Alternatives:
❌ First-time buyers: Unless exceptionally high income ❌ Budget-conscious: Property taxes alone are $3,200+/month ❌ Short-term owners (<5 years): High transaction costs ❌ Remote workers: Not maximizing train commute value ❌ Smaller families: May not need large homes schools accommodate
Millburn vs. Comparable Markets
Millburn Short Hills vs. Livingston - Price difference: Millburn $1.32M vs. Livingston $700K (88% premium) - School ranking: Millburn #1 NJ vs. Livingston #5 NJ - Verdict: Livingston offers 80% of the value at 53% of the cost
Millburn Short Hills vs. Montclair - Price difference: Millburn $1.32M vs. Montclair $850K (55% premium) - School ranking: Millburn #1 NJ vs. Montclair #21 NJ - Lifestyle: Millburn more suburban/private, Montclair more urban/arts-focused - Verdict: Millburn for pure academics, Montclair for diversity/culture
Millburn Short Hills vs. Ridgewood (Bergen County) - Price difference: Millburn $1.32M vs. Ridgewood $950K (39% premium) - School ranking: Millburn #1 NJ vs. Ridgewood #12 NJ - Commute: Both excellent (Ridgewood 25 min to NYC) - Verdict: Ridgewood offers better value, Millburn has edge in schools
Market Trends & 2025 Outlook
Inventory Shortage Continues
Millburn has chronic low inventory: - Active listings: 40-60 homes (vs. 100-150 in pre-2020) - Days on market: 30-45 days (quality homes) - Multiple offers: Common on well-priced homes - Above-ask sales: 10-15% of transactions
Price Appreciation
- 2020-2024: +18% cumulative growth
- 2025 forecast: +3-5% (slower but steady)
- 10-year outlook: Millburn historically appreciates 4-6%/year
Interest Rate Impact
Millburn buyers less rate-sensitive than average market: - All-cash buyers: 40% unaffected by rates - High-income buyers: Can absorb higher payments - Refinance strategy: Many buying now, planning to refi if rates drop
COVID-19 Lasting Effects
Pandemic accelerated Millburn demand: - Remote work: NYC executives moved to suburbs permanently - Space premium: Larger homes, home offices now essential - School quality: Virtual learning highlighted Millburn's excellence - Permanent shift: Demand unlikely to reverse
Common Mistakes Luxury Buyers Make
1. Underestimating Total Monthly Cost
Many focus on mortgage payment, forgetting: - Property tax: $3,200-$4,000/month - Insurance: $400-$600/month - Maintenance: $1,000+/month (landscaping, pool, repairs) - Utilities: $500-$800/month (large homes) - Country club: $1,500-$3,000/month (if joining)
Total monthly: $15,000-$20,000+ (not just $7,000 P&I)
2. Not Touring Multiple Neighborhoods
Millburn has distinct micro-markets with different vibes: - Short Hills Village: Walkable, train-oriented - Glenwood: Large estates, privacy - Millburn Center: Downtown living - Old Short Hills: Ultra-exclusive gated
Tour all areas before deciding.
3. Skipping Pre-Approval for Jumbo
Jumbo loans require extensive documentation: - 2 years tax returns - All bank/investment statements - Explanation of large deposits - Verification of assets, income
Get pre-approved 60+ days before house hunting to identify documentation gaps.
4. Ignoring Renovation Costs
Many Millburn homes are 40-70 years old: - Kitchen/bath updates: $100K-$250K - Roof replacement: $25K-$50K - HVAC systems: $20K-$40K - Window replacement: $30K-$60K
Budget $100K-$300K for renovations on older homes.
How to Win in a Competitive Millburn Market
1. Get Pre-Approved Early (Jumbo-Specific)
Work with lender experienced in Millburn luxury market: - Understands high-balance jumbo underwriting - Pre-underwrites your file (not just credit check) - Provides strong pre-approval letter - Can close in 30 days or less
2. Waive Financing Contingency (If Comfortable)
Strong buyers waive financing contingency: - Shows seller you're serious - Reduces deal-kill risk - Only if you're confident in approval - Have backup cash if financing falls through
3. Be Ready to Act Fast
Best homes sell in days: - Tour within 24 hours of listing - Make decision same day/next day - Submit offer before first weekend open house - Include escalation clause
4. Consider Off-Market Opportunities
Many Millburn sales happen off-market: - Work with local agent plugged into community - Attend community events, network - Send letters to homes you love - Be ready to move quickly
Ready to Buy in Millburn Short Hills?
If you're ready to invest in New Jersey's #1-ranked school district and secure your family's educational future, I can help you navigate the luxury mortgage process.
As a mortgage advisor specializing in Essex County luxury markets, I provide: - Jumbo loan expertise: Loans up to $3M+ - Portfolio loan access: For business owners, high-net-worth buyers - Fast closings: 30 days or less on strong files - Competitive rates: Shopping 15+ jumbo lenders for best terms - White-glove service: Personalized support for luxury buyers
Let's discuss your Millburn Short Hills financing strategy and create a plan to make your luxury home purchase a reality.
📞 Call Jimmy Joseph MBA: (908) 698-0150 🌐 Get Pre-Approved: [https://www.cmghomeloans.com/mysite/jimmy-joseph](https://www.cmghomeloans.com/mysite/jimmy-joseph)
Serving: Millburn, Short Hills, Livingston, Montclair, and all of Essex County NJ
---
*Millburn Short Hills represents the apex of New Jersey luxury real estate. With the #1 school district, 23-minute NYC commute, and generational wealth-building potential, this market rewards buyers who understand its unique dynamics. Whether you're relocating from Manhattan, upgrading within Essex County, or building your family's legacy, Millburn offers an unparalleled combination of education, lifestyle, and long-term value.*