Last Updated: November 6, 2025 | Expert Strategies by Jimmy Joseph MBA
Quick Answer: How to Win in 2025 Market
Strong Offer Components: (1) Pre-approval letter, (2) Competitive price (research comps), (3) Reasonable contingencies, (4) Flexible closing date, (5) Earnest money deposit 1-3%
Bidding War Tactics: Escalation clause, waive appraisal gap, increase deposit, personal letter, quick close Negotiation Power: Motivated sellers (60+ days listed, relocation, divorce, estate sales)
---
Researching Comparable Sales (Comps)
Find 3-5 recent sales: - Same neighborhood (within 0.5 miles) - Similar sq ft (±10%) - Same bed/bath count - Sold in last 3-6 months - Similar condition/updates
Sources: Zillow, Redfin, Realtor.com (shows sold prices), your agent's MLS access
Example (Bergen County): - Subject property: 3BR/2BA, 1,800 sq ft, updated kitchen, $650K asking - Comp 1: 3BR/2BA, 1,750 sq ft, similar condition, sold $625K (2 months ago) - Comp 2: 3BR/2.5BA, 1,850 sq ft, updated, sold $655K (1 month ago) - Comp 3: 3BR/2BA, 1,800 sq ft, needs updating, sold $595K (3 months ago) - Fair price range: $625K-$645K (subject is updated like Comp 2 but smaller)
Offer Strategy: - Asking $650K (5 days on market) = Offer $640K (slightly below ask, room to negotiate) - Asking $650K (<3 days, multiple interest) = Offer $650K+ (competitive)
---
Understanding Contingencies
Inspection Contingency **What it is**: Right to professional inspection; request repairs or back out if major issues found **Standard**: 7-10 days after acceptance **When to waive**: Never (unless you're an experienced investor buying as-is for teardown) **Negotiation**: Instead of waiving, shorten timeline (5 days vs 10) or cap repair requests ($5K minimum)
Appraisal Contingency **What it is**: If appraisal comes in below purchase price, you can renegotiate or walk away **Standard**: Included in most contracts **When to waive**: Only if you have cash to cover gap (Example: $650K price, $630K appraisal = bring extra $20K down payment) **2025 Market**: Appraisals typically meet price in balanced markets; waiving this is risky
Financing Contingency **What it is**: If you can't secure mortgage, you can cancel and get earnest money back **Standard**: 30-45 days **When to waive**: ONLY if you're paying cash (have proof of funds) **Note**: Even with pre-approval, keep this contingency (job loss, credit changes, property issues can prevent final approval)
Home Sale Contingency **What it is**: Offer contingent on selling your current home first **Seller perspective**: Weak (they're waiting on your sale) **When to use**: If you MUST sell first (can't carry two mortgages) **Strategy**: Offer higher price to compensate for inconvenience, or list your home first before making offers
---
Crafting Your Offer
Offer Price **Competitive Market** (homes selling <7 days): Offer at or above asking **Balanced Market** (homes selling 15-30 days): Offer 2-5% below asking **Slow Market** (homes sitting 60+ days): Offer 5-10% below asking
Escalation Clause: "I offer $640K, but will automatically outbid other offers by $5K increments up to max $665K" - Pros: Ensures you don't overpay if no competition, but win if there is - Cons: Seller knows your max price
Earnest Money Deposit (EMD) **Standard**: 1-2% of purchase price ($6,500-$13,000 on $650K home) **Competitive Offer**: 3% ($19,500) - shows serious commitment **Held in escrow**: Returned if you cancel for contingency reason; applied to down payment at closing
Higher EMD = Stronger offer (shows you're less likely to walk away)
Closing Date Flexibility **Ask seller's preference**: Some want quick close (financial stress, already moved), others need time (finding new home, lease-back) **Standard**: 30-45 days **Competitive Tactic**: "Flexible closing date - can close as early as 21 days or give you 60 days if needed"
Personal Letter to Seller **Use if**: Emotionally motivated seller (longtime family home, estate sale) **Include**: Your story (why you love the home, how you'll care for it, family plans) **Don't include**: Protected class info (race, religion, family status - Fair Housing violation) **Effectiveness**: Works 20-30% of time in emotional situations; irrelevant to investors/flippers
---
Bidding War Strategies
Situation: Multiple Offers Likely
Before You Bid: 1. Get pre-approved (not pre-qualified) 2. Research comps (know max value) 3. Set your absolute ceiling (price you won't exceed) 4. Have earnest money ready (wire funds to escrow same day)
Your Strongest Offer: - Price: At or above asking (use escalation clause if unsure) - EMD: 3% (double the standard 1.5%) - Inspection: Keep it, but shorten to 5 days - Appraisal: Offer to cover gap up to $10K-20K (shows commitment) - Financing: Pre-approval from reputable lender (include letter) - Closing: Flexible (ask seller preference in advance) - Extras: Personal letter, proof of funds for down payment
Escalation Clause Example: "Initial offer: $650,000 Escalation: Will exceed highest competing offer by $5,000 increments Maximum: $675,000 Proof: Require copy of competing offer to verify escalation"
When to Walk Away ❌ Bidding exceeds comps by 10%+ (you'll lose money on appraisal or resale) ❌ Seller demands all contingencies waived (too risky unless you're investor) ❌ You're uncomfortable with the price (buyer's remorse likely) ❌ Emotional attachment overriding financial logic
Remember: There will always be another house
---
Negotiating Repairs After Inspection
Inspection reveals issues - now what?
Option 1: Request Repairs **Ask seller to fix**: Major safety issues (electrical, structural, roof) **Likelihood**: 50/50 (depends on market and seller motivation) **Risk**: Seller does cheap fix; you don't control quality
Option 2: Request Credit at Closing **Better approach**: "Credit $8,000 at closing for roof replacement" **Benefits**: You control the repair; choose your contractor; can shop around **Seller perspective**: Easier than coordinating repairs themselves
Option 3: Renegotiate Price **Major issues found**: "Reduce price by $15,000 to account for foundation repair" **When to use**: If seller refuses repairs/credits **Risk**: Seller may reject and move to backup offer
Option 4: Walk Away **Deal-breakers**: Mold, structural damage >$30K, active leaks, foundation failure **Contingency protects you**: Get earnest money refunded
Negotiation Tip: Prioritize big-ticket items (roof $15K, HVAC $10K, foundation $25K), let minor issues go (cosmetic, <$500 fixes). Asking for everything makes you look difficult.
---
Frequently Asked Questions
1. How much should I offer on a house?
Answer: Research comps first. Hot market (<7 days on market): Offer at or 3-5% above asking. Balanced (15-30 days): Offer 2-5% below asking. Slow market (60+ days): Offer 5-10% below. Factor: condition (pristine = closer to ask; needs work = below), motivation (estate/relocation = room to negotiate). Example: $650K ask, fair value $635-645K, 45 days listed → offer $625K (4% below ask, room to negotiate to $635-640K).
2. Should I waive the inspection contingency to win a bidding war?
Answer: NO (99% of time). Inspection protects you from $10K-50K+ in hidden issues (foundation, roof, mold, electrical). Instead: (1) Shorten inspection timeline (5 days vs 10), (2) Limit repair requests to >$5K items, (3) Waive appraisal gap up to $X. Only waive inspection if: (1) You're investor buying as-is, (2) You've done pre-inspection with your own inspector, (3) You have $30K+ cash reserves for surprises.
3. What is an escalation clause and should I use one?
Answer: Escalation clause automatically outbids competing offers up to your max. Example: "Offer $640K, will exceed other offers by $5K up to max $665K." Pros: Don't overpay if no competition; win if there is. Cons: Seller knows your ceiling; may shop your offer to get higher bids. Use when: (1) Hot market with multiple offers likely, (2) You love the home and don't want to lose it, (3) Comps support your max price. Don't use when: (1) You want to lowball, (2) Seller may use it against you.
4. How much earnest money should I put down?
Answer: Standard: 1-2% ($6,500-$13,000 on $650K). Competitive offer: 3% ($19,500). Note: Held in escrow, returned if you cancel for contingency reason (inspection, appraisal, financing), applied to down payment at closing. Higher EMD shows: (1) Serious commitment, (2) Less likely to walk away, (3) Stronger financial position. Don't put down more than you can afford to lose if you breach contract.
5. What happens if the appraisal comes in low?
Answer: Three options: (1) Negotiate down: Ask seller to lower price to appraised value (they often agree, especially if no other offers). (2) Increase down payment: Bring extra cash to cover gap (Example: $650K price, $630K appraisal = bring extra $20K). (3) Walk away: If you have appraisal contingency, cancel and get earnest money back. 2025 Market: Appraisals typically meet price in balanced markets. Low appraisals happen when: (1) You overpaid in bidding war, (2) Home was overpriced, (3) Market shifted between offer and appraisal.
6. Should I write a personal letter to the seller?
Answer: Yes, if: (1) Longtime family home (emotional attachment), (2) Estate sale (heirs care about legacy), (3) Tight-knit neighborhood (seller cares about neighbors). Include: Why you love the home, how you'll care for it, family plans. Don't include: Race, religion, family status (Fair Housing violation). No, if: (1) Investor/flipper seller (only care about price), (2) Bank-owned/foreclosure, (3) Corporate seller. Effectiveness: 20-30% in emotional situations; 0% with investors. Won't overcome weak offer, but can be tiebreaker between equal offers.
7. How long do I have to respond to a counteroffer?
Answer: Seller typically gives you 24-48 hours to respond to counteroffer. Don't rush: (1) Review numbers carefully, (2) Consult your agent and lender, (3) Determine if it's acceptable or needs another counter. Negotiation dance: Buyer offers $625K → Seller counters $645K → Buyer counters $635K → Seller accepts. Average: 2-3 rounds of negotiation. Seller deadline pressure: If seller says "respond in 1 hour or we move to backup offer," it's negotiation tactic (but they may mean it in hot market).
8. What's the difference between pending and contingent status?
Answer: Contingent: Offer accepted, but subject to contingencies (inspection, appraisal, financing). Buyer can still back out. Pending: All contingencies satisfied, deal moving to closing (unlikely to fall through). As buyer: You can submit backup offer on contingent listing (if first buyer walks away). Timeline: Contingent period typically 30-45 days; pending period 0-14 days until closing.
9. Can I make an offer on a house that hasn't been listed yet?
Answer: Yes, but challenging. Coming Soon: Listed privately, no MLS yet. Agent may accept offers early. Off-Market: Owner considering selling. Submit written offer with pre-approval. Advantages: (1) No competition, (2) Negotiate directly, (3) Seller may accept less (no marketing costs). Disadvantages: (1) No comps to gauge price, (2) Seller may wait for better offer, (3) May not be motivated. How to find: (1) Drive neighborhoods, look for FSBOs, (2) Ask agent for pocket listings, (3) Direct mail to homeowners in target area.
10. What should I do if my offer is rejected?
Answer: (1) Ask why: Price too low? Terms unacceptable? Competing offer? (2) Counter higher: If price was issue and you have room. (3) Improve terms: Increase EMD, shorten contingencies, flexible closing. (4) Walk away: If seller is unreasonable or it's priced above comps. (5) Submit backup offer: If they accepted another offer (25% of deals fall through during contingency period). Don't: Get emotional, badmouth seller, make rash decisions. Do: Learn from experience, keep searching. Average buyer makes 2-3 offers before acceptance in competitive markets.
---
Next: [Home Closing Process Guide](/blog/home-closing-process-guide)
📞 Ready to make an offer? Call [(908) 698-0150](tel:9086980150)